Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

PPC II & IPE II Clinical Question Presentation Assignment Guide: Understanding the Rubric

This guide provides instructions for the EBM II clinical question presentation assignment.

Written Response

There is an example of a written response in the PPC II AIMS site.

Presentation Style

  • Maintained eye contact most of the time
  • Did not rely solely on notes
    • Students may use notes. Do not overly rely on your notes.
  • Appeared generally relaxed
  • Movements and gestures enhanced delivery
  • Most sentences were complete and grammatically correct
  • Voice was clear and audible
  • Pace was appropriate

Organization and Timing

  • Sequence was logical
  • Transitions were clear
  • Within 2 minute of allotted time (e.g. within 28 to 42 minutes for a 30-40 minute presentation)

Depth of Knowledge

  • Most information was relevant to the question
  • The 7-steps approach was utilized when providing the response
    • See Professor McEwen's lecture (COM students) or Dr. Hoffmaster's lecture (COP students) for more information about the 7-steps approach.
  • The PP-ICO method was utilized to come up with ultimate clinical question
  • The PP-ICONS method was utilized to critique the literature
  • Literature Search: Named database(s) searched. Provided search strategy and reasons for selecting the article.
  • Critique of the literature was mostly accurate and complete
  • Primary literature presented generally supports claims

Question/Answer Session

  • Answered questions concisely
  • Appeared confident when answering questions
  • Answered >50% of questions without assistance

Written Response

  • The introduction of the paper orients the reader to the clinical question
  • Identified all relevant literature resources
  • The recommendation is stated clearly with the appropriate level of certainty (or uncertainty)
  • Reference citation formats are appropriately formatted (consistent with the Uniform Requirements)
  • Paragraphs are organized logically/appropriately.
  • Sentences and paragraphs transition smoothly.
  • Correct grammar and spelling are used throughout the written response

Professional Conduct (failure to achieve in this area will result in a meeting with the course director)

For Zoom presentations, students are not required to wear their white coat and name badge. Semi-professional attire is required.

In person sessions:

The student was:

  • dressed appropriately
    • Group members are wearing professional attire.
  • wearing a clean white coat
  • displaying their name badge
  • respectful to other presenters